Dear Julian,
I strongly believe that there should be a vote at the end of the
negotiations so that people can decide what they want. There are several very powerful reasons for this,
and I am sharing some of them with you here.
- The
original referendum was very close.
It was only 52% to 48% which is very close, and now more people
have dropped off the electoral register than the majority in the referendum.
- At
the time we did not know what leave would mean. We were told many things including such
things as (many of these come from “Vote leave for a fairer Britain” http://www.voteleavetakecontrol.org/vote_leave_for_a_fairer_britain.html
- We
would be better off with Brexit (all reputable bodies say that we will be
worse off under any deal, especially a “no deal” scenario.
- There
will be £350 million a week for the NHS (as the economy is already estimated
to be £250 a week smaller than if we had decided to remain this is
clearly not true).
- We
would have as good or better trade terms under Brexit (absolutely not
true)
- “Wages will be higher for working
people outside the EU… because pay will no longer be undercut by
uncontrolled migration.” All economic forecasters are saying that
we will be worse off under any Brexit scenario.
- After we Vote Leave, there won’t be
a sudden change that disrupts the economy. – This will clearly not
be true if there is no deal, and even with a deal many companies are
talking or relocating part or all of their business to Europe.
- There’ll
be no damage to trade with the EU – something which is clearly untrue
under any scenario, and disastrously so under a no deal Brexit.
- Given
that only 52% wanted to leave and 48% to remain, it was also clear that
there was no uniformity of opinion of what people wanted, going from at
one end people who wanted full integration in the “United States of Europe”
through reluctant remainers who thought it would on balance be better to
reluctant leavers who thought on balance it would be better to leave to
hard Brexiters who wanted no deal.
In this situation it is clear that we should be going for the least
possible Brexit (in accordance with only 52% wanting it all). But that is
not going to be offered.
- There
are around 1 million new adults now entitled to vote
- In
any sensible deal there is a vote to call for negotiations, and then
another vote to decide whether people accept the result. If you think of negotiations between
businesses and trades unions there is a vote to empower the trade union to
negotiate, and then a vote on whether or not to accept the terms. NB if the terms are not accepted then
the status quo is preserved, not all the workers leave the business.
So, I am asking to press the Prime Minister and Brexit Secretary to
support a vote on the results of their negotiations, and to support such a vote. Anything else would be an abrogation of
democracy.
If the Brexit terms agreed are as good as ministers claim then there
should be resounding support, and if people do not want whatever have been
negotiated they should be allowed to say so.
Best wishes
Tom.
Tom
Franklin
